UK time is: 21:01:32
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Manchester City 2 - Newcastle Utd 1

City of Manchester Stadium


Attendance: 46,067


The most expensively assembled side in the world struggled to overturn a combative and determined Utd side but with a little help from their friend in the middle, and a cracking goal from a fellow Mag of all people, the 2-1 result in City's favour is nonetheless what matters most in the headlines.

That Newcastle could be considered a rag-tag team, as was suggested by a neutral observer, is perhaps pushing it, given that several of those on the field were purchased for £5m+ fees. However, the stark reality is that those fees are dwarfed by the money spent on the squad at Roberto Mancini's disposal. Where once Newcastle Utd sat proudly as big spenders at the top table, so those tables have turned. And yet, the gulf in class was not as obvious as one might think. In fact, as it turned out, it took bad officiating to really settle the match.

Referee Martin Atkinson is actually a fairly decent official generally but he had a stinker today. When De Jong literally snapped Hatem Ben Arfa in half in the first few minutes, any discipline may have seemed harsh particularly to a neutral, given that the Dutchman got the ball. But the manner of the tackle and the trailing leg which essentially did the damage, is part and parcel of his game and the reputation that precedes him.

With Newcastle's most potent striking option on his way to hospital, they still took the game to their hosts. But Atkinson was about the drop the first of two clangers which ultimately proved to be the real difference between the sides. Williamson's last ditch tackle was close but the defender clearly got the ball first. Atkinson may have been badly sighted but chose not to confer with his assistant and awarded a penalty, which Tevez converted to make it 1-0.

But that scoreline changed quickly when good work from Gutierrez saw the Argentine drive powerfully into the box before picking up a loose ball from his own pass, before smashing the equaliser off the underside of the bar.

Newcastle were then forced into a change at the back with Coloccini picking up a groin injury. Sol Campbell came on as his replacement and acquitted himself well in his first league start as a Magpie of the North Easterly variety.

The second half saw a swing in dominance from visitors to hosts and Manicini mixed things up by bringing on Adebayor who proved to be a handful. But it was the next substitution which saw Newcastle supporter, Adam Johnson arrive in timely fashion to glide between two defenders and slot the ball into the bottom of Krul's net to seal the victory.

Having started with his top scorer on the bench and Shola Ameobi in replacement, Hughton threw on Andy Carroll in place of the struggling Nolan. But it was Ameobi who was to be denied a stonewall penalty when he turned cutely in the box, only to be clearly tripped by the backtracking Lescott. Atkinson's decision to wave play on summed up his contribution for the afternoon.

With both sides playing a 4-5-1, it was probably not surprising to see the midfield dominate, and yet it was an entertaining game. Hughton will have been disappointed that more clear cut chances weren't created and the possession wasn't turned into more goals in the first half. But that is an implication of the more compact formation he has preferred so far.

A narrow defeat to genuine title-contenders is something that most fans may have accepted more readily at the start of the season. But despite disappointing results against Blackpool and Stoke there has been much promise of better things than dared be expected going into the game. But the manner of the defeat is what will cut deepest, even given the valiant and admirable approach to the game. Though several players can take heart from impressive displays, not least those in the engine room, Joey Barton and Cheik Tiote, who both put in good shifts and showed an improved understanding.

However, Hughton must ponder the future without potentially his most potent attacking force and the fans without an exciting player that had really caught the imagination and promised much more to come. Perhaps also the near future without a success story of last year, Coloccini, who has brought his good form into the Premiership. While three points are important, the injuries sustained in defeat could well prove to be the biggest cost of the day.

Star Player

Cheik Tiote

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The Journalist

Writer: BowburnMag Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday October 3 2010

Time: 10:46PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Citeh were there for the taking, we just aint got "it!" - thoiught Shola was poor, and Carroll no better, with Ben Arfa going off tho, we were stuck with the subs we needed to make...
Report Abuse
04/10/2010 07:00:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. OldLeazes 220
2. officemonkey 172
3. billybobcat 134
4. Hugo45Viana 130
5. Toon_NoMatterWot 110
7. Gillyboat 84
8. daftladguy 82
9. thecorner 82
10. Finn_the_Dog 73

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
9. West Ham 30 11 9 10 3 42
10. Stoke 30 12 6 12 -3 42
11. Crystal Palace 30 9 9 12 -5 36
12. Newcastle 30 9 8 13 -15 35
13. Everton 30 8 10 12 -4 34
14. WBA 30 8 9 13 -12 33
15. Hull City 30 6 10 14 -12 28

Breaking League News

Hasselbaink: 'Swansea City Have The Perfect Model'
» Swansea : 30/03/2015 20:45:01
Wanyama - Don't Come Unstuck Against The Toffees
» Southampton : 30/03/2015 19:57:01
Leicester Returning To Hong Kong
» Leicester City : 30/03/2015 19:35:00
Bale Rush - What Madrid are saying
» Chelsea : 30/03/2015 19:32:01
Blyth's Season Over At Burton
» Leicester City : 30/03/2015 19:28:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Arsenal MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Krul 2%
Taylor 0%
Janmaat 47%
Williamson 0%
Colback 5%
Anita 0%
Sissoko 5%
Gouffran 0%
Cabella 5%
Ameobi 5%
Pérez 21%
Sub:-Gutiérrez 5%
Sub:-Armstrong 5%