Newcastle United - Vintage Manchester Utd!
UK time is: 07:59:25
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Man Utd 3 - Newcastle Utd 0

Old Trafford

16/08/2010 8PM

Attendance: TBC

Vintage Manchester Utd!

Regrettably, sometimes you need to give credit where's it due even if it pains you. Manchester United deserve credit for a straightforward and convincing 3-0 victory over Newcastle tonight. And in particular, after a masterclass in playmaking, Paul Scholes proved just why even at 35 he is still one of the best midfielders at the top level of English football even if he still can't tackle for toffee.

Going into the game, Newcastle fans could be forgiven for a sense of impending doom. Despite storming back up to the top flight at the first time of asking, few fans were under any illusion that the Premiership and a trip to its most successful side would prove to be anything other than a different challenge entirely.

Starting with a predictable 4-5-1 formation, Hughton deployed Nolan in behind lone striker Andy Carroll while Danny Guthrie was missing due to a slight knock. Joey Barton and Alan Smith paired in the middle of the park. James Perch made his Newcastle debut and the remaining eleven effectively picked itself.

And with half an hour gone, some dogged defending and determination had kept the scoreline at 0-0, while at the other end, Andy Carroll was left to rue a very good chance to put his side ahead. But three minutes later, complacency from Gutierrez saw him dispossessed inside the Newcastle half and with Enrique committed outside of him and Coloccini caught napping, a clever Scholes' ball found Berbatov in the box. Despite the attentions of the advancing Enrique, Berbatov kept his nerve to drive the ball into Harper's far corner.

More complacency led to the second goal, with sloppy defensive play, Darren Fletcher capitalising on a cross from Evra who found himself with far too much time in the box. And yet his ball to Fletcher still gave opportunity for the defence to deal with it, but the Scot turned all too easily to fire past Harper for 2-0.

And from that point, it really was cruise control for Manchester United, who might have increased the lead by several more. As it was, a cameo appearance by another Old Trafford legend, saw Giggs come on and who else but Scholes teased an inviting ball into the box and the veteran Welshman steered his volley across Harper and into the bottom corner for 3-0.

Expectations may have been low in the Magpie camp before the game and the reality is that Newcastle will come up against far worse sides than Manchester United this season. But the air of arrogance that always threatened to backfire last season may need to be addressed. The three goals proof enough that complacency on the ball will not go unpunished at this level as it did in last season's campaign.

A shaky start for James Perch will not have done the young right back any favours. The over-indulgent footwork of Coloccini, Enrique and Gutierrez last season was ably defused and exploited by a much more capable side than any they faced in the Championship and that will also need to be cut out.

A midfield sorely lacking in pace and invention was completely outplayed by old man Scholes and Fletcher, Nolan trundling about to little effect and Joey 'this year will be his big season' Barton doing little to justify his inclusion in the side. Alan Smith offered little in the way of going forward but at least threw himself into the occasion, literally.

Upfront, a stand-out performance went some way to proving that despite his doubters (including yours truly), Andy Carroll may well have the presence, ability and appetite for the top flight. But with little support around him, he was left to plough a very lonely furrow with little to show for it.

The Premiership season will prove to be a marathon rather than a sprint but on this display, it's difficult to imagine anything other than a long, hard road ahead.

Newcastle - Steve Harper 6, James Perch 5, Mike Williamson 6, Fabricio Coloccini 6, Jose Enrique 6, Wayne Routledge 5, Alan Smith 6, Joey Barton 4, Jonas Gutierrez 5, Kevin Nolan 5, Andy Carroll 7.

Subs - Tim Krul, James Tavernier, Ryan Taylor, Haris Vuckic, Nile Ranger, Xisco, Shola Ameobi.

Star Player

Andy Carroll

The Journalist

Writer: BowburnMag Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday August 16 2010

Time: 11:32PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
As per your instructions in the forum. I have read your well thought out piece. Nicely structured, with fine analysis. Since I read this, you're not allowed to tell me to ***** off, as you threatened to do in the forum.
Report Abuse
16/08/2010 23:49:00

That sounds fair enough.
Report Abuse
16/08/2010 23:56:00

Above comments - Chortle! A very unusually well balanced match report. Good to see you barcodes back where you belong & look forward to our games later in the season. Villa fan in peace.
Report Abuse
17/08/2010 06:32:00

Great report BBM, thought Carroll did really well considering the supply he had, but, he should have scored that header, might not have changed the game but it would have given the lad some confidence... Man Utd will beat better teams than us by 3 goals, we didnt let our heads go down but the game did hilight some shortfalls, Perch, Routledge looked very lightweight amongst others who simply didnt have a good game.
Report Abuse
17/08/2010 06:32:00

Great report and fully agree with Bartons 4, maybe it was just the quality of the opposition but on this display he wont win anymore England caps, his passing, tackling and tracking were as bad as his tash and he looked so off the pace. Perch looked a bit ropey and Routledge looked a lot slower in this league.
Report Abuse
17/08/2010 07:55:00

Too long for me, the scoreline says it all for me, hears to many more floggings.
Report Abuse
17/08/2010 10:28:00

Now now Teddy, u come across as a bit of a dick.
Report Abuse
17/08/2010 12:45:00

being generous in giving perch and nolans 5s
Report Abuse
17/08/2010 13:15:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Toon_NoMatterWot 104
3. billybobcat 40
4. keggy_keagal 39
5. officemonkey 39
6. Sir Laz 28
7. Mcnamee67 27
8. vin1892 19
9. The Owl 18
10. daftladguy 16

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
14. WBA 26 8 8 10 -8 32
15. AFC Bournemouth 26 7 7 12 -14 28
16. Swansea 26 6 9 11 -10 27
17. Norwich 26 6 6 14 -20 24
18. Newcastle 26 6 6 14 -22 24
19. Sunderland 26 6 5 15 -18 23
20. Aston Villa 25 3 7 15 -20 16

Newcastle United Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

(Video) A View From The Other Side
Man City : 14/02/2016 07:38:00
Norwich City 2 - 2 West Ham
Norwich : 14/02/2016 07:00:00
Guidolin Changed Shape To Face Southampton's 3-4-3
Swansea : 14/02/2016 00:32:01
Sunderland : 13/02/2016 19:55:01
Ritchie: We have to bounce back
AFC Bournemouth : 13/02/2016 19:50:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Chelsea MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Elliot 0%
Janmaat 0%
Taylor 0%
Coloccini 0%
Aarons 0%
Shelvey 0%
Tiote 0%
Sissoko 0%
Wijnaldum 0%
Townsend 0%
Mitrovic 0%
Sub - Colback 0%
Sub - Lascelles 0%
Sub - Doumbia 0%