Player ratings v Derby
Given - 6 - Not much he could do for either.
Beye - 7 - Am liking the lad. Good raiding today.
Rozenhal - 4 - Rank. Bottled the first goal and looked a twat for the second.
Cacapa - 5 - Lucky not to be the villain after Marriner bottled the penalty decision.
N`Zogbia - 6 - Wasted where he is.
Smith - 4 - Never a midfielder, doesn`t suit 4-4-2 or 4-3-3.
Barton - 4 - If only he played the game he talked.
Butt - 6 - Steady. Should be our skipper.
Milner - 5 - Tried but lacked his usual quality.
Martins - 4 - Anonymous before his African holiday.
Viduka - 8 - Stand out MOTM by far. The only quality on display.