Vital Football

Latest Newcastle United News

The Carroll debacle, a view among many

The Carroll debacle, a view among many

A few days on, and with the Sunday press undoubtedly yet to report on the stories behind the story, TOTT tries to make sense of the Carroll debacle.

The media reports on the day would tend to suggest that the sale of Carroll was a last minute thing. Is this really feasible? Perhaps a clue is that the Sun were ready to roll on the morning of transfer deadline day, with a story of a £30million bid and an offer to triple Carroll`s wages.

Both Carroll and the club have had something to say, Carroll that he was forced out, and the "club" pointing to very reluctantly accepting his transfer request. Pardew stressed that Carroll didn`t have to get on the helicopter, whilst the club-friendly media fail to point out that Ashley did not have to provide his chopper to a player whose manager emphatically stated from December onwards who was not for sale.

All sides seem to seek to draw a line under the situation. Carroll is gone. Pardew emphatically says that Carroll is not here, Carroll`s Liverpool press conference has their club officials stunting the journalists` questions. Club captain, Kevin Nolan has urged moving ahead, whilst the "club" in the form of Chairman Llambias deflected attention by attacking Newcastle`s modern legend, Alan Shearer.

Yes it is true that Shearer`s 8 games in charge yielded 5 points, but a relegation season is 38 games long. The Chairman was responsible for running the club for 38 games, not just 8. In that time, he was responsible for the dealings that led to Keegan`s successful claim for constructive dismissal, the tribunal highlighting club statements that were "untrue", and that there was a "repudiation of contract".

The long and the short of it is that the Chairman was responsible for the circumstances of the constructive dismissal, the appointment of a caretaker, the further appointment of another manager with a history of heart problems, who then suffered another heart problem, plus a further caretaker appointment in the 30 games before Shearer.

Shearer has scored over 200 goals for the club. Llambias is on his way towards 200 managerial appointments, which raises the question of the dismissal of Hughton. Hughton`s achievements are well documented on TOTT. The summary version is that he has the highest win ratio of any manager in Newcastle history, in what is a venerable list.

There would seem to be few who would suggest that Hughton was less than dignified, and had united a disparate squad towards a common goal. Questions may be asked as to whether Hughton`s modern democratic style of management was in fact in conflict with the aims of the club. Hughton`s distinguished football career as a player, as well as a coach under a catalogue of English national managers, qualifies him as a true football person and team player.

Would Carroll have left if Hughton was still manager?

From Pardew`s account of the final day, he seems to have done little to stop the transfer request. It will be remembered, however, that he repeatedly said in recorded conversations, that Carroll was not for sale, that he was going nowhere at any price. Carroll has been sold, he has gone.

It seems reasonable to assume that if Hughton were still in charge, the conversation might have been longer than Pardew`s appears to have been, according to Pardew`s own account. It is conjecture, but perhaps the team spirit might have been emphasised. Perhaps the reasons that Carroll had been a success in this club might have been outlined, along with the opportunity to revisit the contract situation in the summer.

Financially, Carroll does benefit from the deal. There are two others who have also gained advantage, Ashley and Carroll`s agent. £35million is a huge figure, as no doubt is Carroll`s new wage. A percentage of that is also potentially huge.

It does not demean the player to note that he is young. His talent is clearly in his endeavour, enthusiasm, energy and contribution on the field. People will form their own judgements as to how astute he might be to the ways of the world off the field. Could it be that he was set up by those around him with much to gain?

There will be no investigation as to whether Premier League rules were breached about approaches through the media, since the person to make the complaint is now £35million richer.

The issue of who got onto the helicopter and who provided the helicopter has already been covered. Who signed the transfer request and who accepted the offer is the same issue. What are the long term implications?

The club has been a reflection of the local population in the past. Traditionally, this has consisted of a hard working set of players with a large input from local talent. The number 9 shirt is renowned, welcoming of players from outside the region, such as Supermac, Cole, Ferdinand, Keeble and many others. The true legends are local lads, such as Milburn, Shearer and it could have been Carroll.

In years to come, the leading protagonist may well reflect that, like others before him, he has made the journey away. He will make a fortune. With a 5 year contract, he may never return. When his playing days are over, Andy may well reflect that he was a hero for a season and a half. He may never become a local legend. Realistically, if he succeeds, he will go down in Anflied folklore among a catalogue of other non-Merseysiders, maybe even progress to the top sides in Europe, but the 200 goals for his home team are unlikely to ever be achieved.

Although a big figure, commercially Carroll may never be as big as he could have been playing for Newcastle. The £35million could have been dwarfed by commercial income as a Geordie playing for Geordies. In the short term, his fee only just about covers the loss of being relegated for a season, increasingly a possibility with the absence of the perennial support striker, Ameobi.

This also sends a message, not just within the club, but to the rest of the football world. Every player has a price, Newcastle United is a feeder club, producing talent that can be bought, whether players come from locally, or from overseas using us as a gateway to the riches of the Premier League. What happens to Enrique, Coloccini, Barton, Nolan, Steve Taylor, Jonas, Tiote and others at the end of the season or in other windows?

The message to the supporters is that we can not expect to challenge for trophies, we are merely a commercial vehicle. Stability, either with players or management, is not desired as a platform for success, the churning of players to make a profit appears to be the aim.

There is quality, if not balance, in the squad. Sadly the depth is not there. The message for quality players is that the club does not want them for the long term. A big enough fee will ensure a transfer to a club with genuine ambition.

If Ashley and his bokkies' runners hang around, they will see a dent in gate revenue, although the figures will show that provided the club turns free, or cheap talent into commodities, there is profit to be made in that direction.

The saddest thing is that the identity of the region has always been reflected by the Tyneside club. This move signals the death of traditional Geordie values, a vibrancy on the field with local talent, a work ethic, a focus for local emotion. Ashley`s Newcastle makes us no more than a feeder club.

Yes, Llambias, Ashley, Pardew and even the team captain can want a line drawn under the issue. The people who love the club, the supporters, have every right to mourn the passing of a heritage for as long as we wish. We have even more right to be angry.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Friday February 4 2011
Time: 9:00AM


Too many mistakes by an Amateur Owner and sidekick, they cannot handle the lordship of the manor. They think by hiding away in their casino's that these problems will go away, not this time. We need to keep the pressure on and run them out of toon. Surprised the media has let them get away with their laughing stock of a time here, so HOWAY, ANY JOURNALISTS READING THIS. DIG THE DIRT AND HELP US GET RID. AN EXCELLENT OPPORTUNITY EXISTS FOR A CLASSIC ARTICLE OR TEN. Excellent as usual rex
04/02/2011 09:12:00
Spot on rexn. Brilliant article. Yet again, the owner says nothing and everything the chairman says is proved to be a lie. Fit and proper? I think not.
04/02/2011 09:22:00
Great post rex. I've just checked through the points that Carroll's goals have got us this season. Take them away and we are 7 worse off - on 23 points and in the bottom 3. I'd like to think that someone else would step up to the plate to replace his goals - but they haven't have they? 2 points out of 9 in the last 3 games tells us that. The squad looks demoralised by events of this week, Pardew admitted as much when talking about Tuesday morning training. The policy of buy cheap and make a profit is unsustainable in the prem. The Andy Carroll's of this world will not come through often enough to sustain the policy - a cursory glance at the remaining strikers at the club will tell you that. They hit the jackpot this season with the emergence of Carroll. They would be foolish to think it can happen every season. The club will not pay the money to keep top players, there is no reason to suggest they would pay top money to attract and keep the best youngsters either. And the policy will make it all the more harder to attract players. A cheap club, cheap managers lead to cheap players ultimately, the game will be up and decent players will go to clubs - as Carroll himself has said - who have ambition.
04/02/2011 12:08:00
'Enjoyed' reading that RexN, as usual I find your articles insightful and informative. Know most of us have been focused on the Carroll fiasco but if you take a step back , as you have pointed out, and add it to the ever growing list of bizarre decisions the club has taken you really do start to wonder when it will all end. Still think Carroll could have refused the move, know he possibly felt that decision was out of his hands but he's a big Lad. Maybe he was 'bullied' by Dez and his own agent, we may never know. Us older ones have been here before but it never fails to amaze and mightily disappoint me how this club, seemingly more than any other, manages to leap from one calamity to another. It's almost as if a higher power see's me/us edging toward happy (I was under Hughton) and takes a huge kick at our gonads.
04/02/2011 14:06:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital F1 - Blog: Sochi Preview

Recent Newcastle United Articles

Video - Championship Goals, 21st-24th April 2017

The Championship season continued with the latest round of games played over the weekend.

Rafa Will Be The Most Important Signing Again

A happy committed Rafa Benitez will give the belief to many that NUFC are on the up again.

Vital View - Championship, 21st-24th April 2017

Brighton would have confirmed the title with a point but defeat kept Newcastle's hopes alive. Wigan are clinging on - Blackburn are two off Birmingham, 21st, and three Forest, 20th.

Newcastle Secure Premier League Return

It might not have been as easy as many would've hoped given how recent form as seen Newcastle United slip from top spot in the Championship, but three points against...

Archived TOTT Articles

TOTT articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Preston MotM
Suggested By:
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
P Brighton 44 28 8 8 92 35
P Newcastle 44 27 7 10 88 40
3 Huddersfield 44 25 6 13 81 3
4 Reading 44 24 7 13 79 1
5 Sheff Wed 44 23 9 12 78 15
6 Fulham 44 21 13 10 76 27
7 Leeds Utd 44 22 7 15 73 14
8 Norwich 44 19 9 16 66 12
9 Brentford 44 18 9 17 63 12
10 Derby County 44 17 12 15 63 2
11 Preston 44 16 13 15 61 2
12 Aston Villa 44 16 13 15 61 0
13 Cardiff 44 16 11 17 59 -2
14 Barnsley 44 15 12 17 57 0
15 Wolves 44 15 10 19 55 -3
16 Ipswich 44 13 16 15 55 -6
17 Bristol City 44 14 9 21 51 -6
18 Burton 44 13 12 19 51 -12
19 Q.P.R. 44 14 8 22 50 -12
20 Forest 44 13 9 22 48 -11
21 Birmingham 44 11 14 19 47 -22
22 Blackburn 44 10 15 19 45 -15
23 Wigan 44 10 11 23 41 -16
R Rotherham 44 5 6 33 21 -58
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Newcastle United Results (view all)

Newcastle United Fixtures (view all)

Apr 28 2017 7:45PM : Cardiff City (a)
Sky Bet Championship
May 7 2017 12:00PM : Barnsley (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

Vital Football Comment