Vital Football

Latest Newcastle United News

A promising start, or a worrying trend?

A promising start, or a worrying trend?

With the Newcastle squad in Portugal and a weekend off, now is a good time to assess the initial impact of the new manager, and with a few days left until the end of the transfer window, what might lay ahead.

By way of background, Hughton was dismissed with the club saying there was a need to go in a different direction, at the helm a manager with more experience than the departed Hughton. There was a lesson on Teesside with the sacking of Southgate, and Boro looking to move in a new direction. They have. The direction has been downwards, from 1 point away from an automatic promotion place, to a couple of places above relegation.

It is worth summarising what the inexperienced manager achieved; the first in Toon history to gain a first time return to the top flight, a record pro rata defensive record, a clean sheet record in a season, the first to be unbeaten at home in all competitions, a record transfer surplus, the best ever win ratio of any Newcastle manager, the first 100+ points season, the first home grown striker developed into an England cap in generations as well as 2 Balkan teenage international squad regulars. Under him, even Shola became a double digit scorer per season striker.

The new manager brings the experience of being sacked from his last 3 positions, leaving 2 clubs in relegation positions, 1 of them already relegated from the Premier League. He has had his successes, 2 fortuitous promotions via playoffs to go with 3 failed attempts. His cup record is quite remarkable, having won the Johnston`s Magnolia Paint Pot with Southampton. His record in the 3rd division is admirable.

The opening press conference was littered with mistakes. Newcastle is a great town, the 930 years of city status ignored. Tribute was paid to Chris Houghton or Howden or whatever his name was. Hughton was once Pardew`s coach at Spurs, so it is easy to forget.

Pardew did, however, promise to "bang on the owner`s door" to release funds to bring in new players. He did promise a new signing by the end of the first week in January. He has clearly been a success, with the only transfers so far being the outbound Wayne Routledge on loan and the making permanent of Ben Arfa`s contract, hopefully fit before the end of the season. Otherwise, plenty of youngsters have gone on loan, reducing the cover available.

He said "In the past I have convinced owners to have faith and trust in me to invest". He is also clearly having his way this time, especially on the craps.

Pardew`s access to the owner, if the Sun is to be believed, is indeed improved over Hughton`s. They were seen, along with Chairman Llambias, in Aspers Casino. Pardew will have been encouraged to see how seriously Ashley takes the value of his contract, having lost in a few rolls of the dice several times Pardew`s pay off in the event of the sack. A cool million disappeared.

When asked what he has brought to the club, Pardew did stress how he has tightened up the defence. The facts speak for themselves. In Hughton`s last 7 games, 11 goals were conceded. In Pardew`s first 7, ignoring the Liverpool match for which he had control for 24 hours previously, that 11 was reduced to 10, including the 3 against 4th division Stevenage.

Hughton`s last 7 games were sacking form, 2 wins, 3 draws and 2 defeats. Pardew`s first 7 have been the sort of form to build from, 2 wins, against 2 of the bottom 3 clubs, 3 draws and 2 defeats. Clear progress there then!

Pardew has claimed successes, notably the demolition of his old club, West Ham, and the contribution of Leon Best, scoring a hat trick on his full Premier League debut for Newcastle. The defeats and dropped points have been easily explained as the fault of the players, starting with the goalkeeper`s distribution putting pressure on the team against Manchester City. It is good to know Pardew was not to blame, according to him.

The Stevenage defeat, probably the most humiliating since Newcastle lost against Hereford, was due to the players "not turning up" and being "tired". Nothing to do with the tactics, then, a right sided player on the left wing, narrowing an already narrow pitch, a right sided player at left back and the sending off of a player who, according to pre-match interviews, was not going to play.

Points were dropped with an injury time equalizer at Sunderland. The fault, according to the manager, was players switching off. This was clearly nothing to do with the late replacement of the left winger with a right sided midfielder, who was not in a position to close down the right back whose shot led to the goal. Damn the players!

The latest was at home against Spurs. The goal on this occasion also came in injury time, the scorer a right winger switching to the left. That fateful goal came minutes after the manager changed the shape of the team, withdrawing a left sided striker to the right side of midfield, the area where the goal came from, in a 4-5-1 formation long abandoned by his predecessor. The fault was not down to the manager`s tactics, it was down to the players being too "gung-ho".

So we have a manager who is flawless, the players letting him down. It must be purely coincidence that his last 4 games have seen 3 injury time goals, Last season, Hughton`s Newcastle went through 51 games in all competitions without conceding a single goal in added time.

Things can still change. Safety is almost assured, with a points total ensuring that 1 more win takes the Toon out of reach of the tallies of the 3 relegated teams last season. The 2nd bottom team are yet to visit St James`, the next game being against a lowly Fuham and the following home opponents Arsenal already beaten away. There is also still time for new players to come in before the transfer deadline, after Pardew has seen the results of his door banging.

The big question is are the points lost late in the game the start of a worrying trend, or are they really the results of the previous inexperienced manager, arguably the most successful in Newcastle history, having failed to deliver a squad capable of seeing games out?

The owner has gambled on the experienced replacement, just as he gambled in Aspers. The result may be totally different. Pardew may well be a winner, and that time might come before he is back in charge of a 3rd division side, where his record is genuinely admirable.

It is encouraging to see that Pardew is ambitious, seeking to challenge the top 10, a position that Hughton kept Newcastle in for over 75% of his Premier League tenure. Indeed, the future is bright, the future is Pardew, for the time being anyway.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Wednesday January 26 2011
Time: 8:00AM


I like it rex.... Spoken like a true journalist who a grudge.. The replacing of hughton with pardew does need an explanation from the club like and this keeps the pressure on
26/01/2011 08:13:00
Interesting read as usual RexN and many thanks for that. Over the years following NUFC there have been many decisions that have baffled, annoyed or just plain old bemused me. However, the employment of Parsnip after the sacking of Chris Hughton is right up there with the very best of those decisions that leave me 'lost for words'. If anyone can explain the rationale behind it I will be extremely grateful.
26/01/2011 15:33:00
Thanks for the comments, gentlemen. Sadly the club are hardly likely to explain this bewildering decision. It makes you wonder if things will get worse.
26/01/2011 18:12:00
great read that
27/01/2011 15:29:00
Shameful how he blames the player's for defeats and takes credit when things go well. It's bound to annoy the players at some point, hopefully they will not let it effect the team spirit.
27/01/2011 15:36:00
Great read as usual, Rexn.
27/01/2011 15:37:00
Thanks again, gentlemen. The thing that strikes me is that if the club is sold, Pardew's tenure will be short. Unless he has learned from his mistakes, both here and at previous clubs, he will be gone before the end of the transfer window in January 2012.
27/01/2011 20:53:00
houghton did well for you he did not put a foot wrong paardrop dose not have a good track recoard
truth sayer ffc
02/02/2011 18:34:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Joshua Tells It As It Is

Recent Newcastle United Articles

3 things Rafa needs to do to ensure Newcastle stay up

3 things Rafa needs to do to ensure Newcastle stay up

Football Flashback

We need to achieve three wins and two draws minimum.

Newcastle Wembley Appearance Doubts

Just got to wait for the authorities to complicate things further by not choosing a simple option

Ashley Tactics Finally Being Regularly Revealed

We've long cottoned on that Mike Ashley only bought Newcastle to benefit himself

Newcastle United Archived Articles

TOTT articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Man U MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Joselu2%
Sub - Atsu0%
Sub - Hayden0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Newcastle United Results (view all)

Newcastle United Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

7.Harry's Boy22
Vital Football Comment