Vital Football

Latest Newcastle United News

Phil Dowd redefines 'shoddy refereeing'

Phil Dowd redefines 'shoddy refereeing'

Newcastle United fell to a strong, and determined Liverpool side on a day Phil Dowd, the referee officiating in the proceedings demonstrated the Football Association's lack of respect for players, or the fans.

How do referees like Phil Dowd, or Rob Styles even manage to come onto a football pitch is utterly questionable.

On this day, Dowd was shocking in his decisions throughout the match. He refused to give Newcastle United any free-kick no matter what happened on the edge of the Liverpool box. He allowed Liverpool's first goal which was miles offside, and later, sent off Joey Barton for good measure.

Bookings also came for United, but not for Liverpool, and in terms of offsides, the lines-men were quite rightly briefed beforehand to only keep out the Toon, and let everything slide for the Reds.

Granted, there was a gulf in class between the two sides, but who are any of the Pools, or Magpies kidding? It was a match exhibiting shocking refereeing.

The final score was 3-0, a respectable one, considering respect is a term one can stretch on Tyneside these days.

But one question, how does the FA expect players and the fans to respect referees, and succeed in their 'respect' campaign, with referees like these?



For the very latest Premier League odds

For massive weekly jackpots - Play the Football Pools Online

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Mehzeb Chowdhury
Date:Sunday May 3 2009
Time: 3:37PM

Comments

0
instead of blaming the shoddy referee you should be blaming your defense, that's what was truly shoddy in that game.
JohnDoe
03/05/2009 15:51:00
0
instead of blaming the shoddy referee you should be blaming your defense, that's what was truly shoddy in that game.
JohnDoe
03/05/2009 15:51:00
0
They should be blaming their owner. What sort of idiot thinks that a person who has never managed a football club in his life can succeed where many seasoned veterans have failed? The fundemental problem is with the club itself, there are no other explinations.
Rocky7
03/05/2009 18:40:00
0
They should be blaming their owner. What sort of idiot thinks that a person who has never managed a football club in his life can succeed where many seasoned veterans have failed? The fundemental problem is with the club itself, there are no other explinations.
Rocky7
03/05/2009 18:40:00
0
This is the problem at Newcastle at the moment, you're expectations about everything are unrealistic. The owners messed up by bringing in Denis Wise to oversea transfers and stopped KK from developing a decent footballing side. I hope Shearer stays there as manager whether Newcastle stay up or are relegated because either way he will make sure that massive changes are put in place to take the club forward. As for blaming he referee for bad decisions, granted the first goal was offside, but Barton had to go! Shearer said that in public on TV. He wants players to play football, not try to put opposition players out of the game. Get real Newcastle fans, tackles like that cannot and should not be condoned. Don't mistake your loyalty to the club and it's players for a sense of fair play. Reverse the position and ask yourselves if one of your players was subjected to an assault like that, would you want him sent off?
eddiedied
04/05/2009 11:02:00
0
This is the problem at Newcastle at the moment, you're expectations about everything are unrealistic. The owners messed up by bringing in Denis Wise to oversea transfers and stopped KK from developing a decent footballing side. I hope Shearer stays there as manager whether Newcastle stay up or are relegated because either way he will make sure that massive changes are put in place to take the club forward. As for blaming he referee for bad decisions, granted the first goal was offside, but Barton had to go! Shearer said that in public on TV. He wants players to play football, not try to put opposition players out of the game. Get real Newcastle fans, tackles like that cannot and should not be condoned. Don't mistake your loyalty to the club and it's players for a sense of fair play. Reverse the position and ask yourselves if one of your players was subjected to an assault like that, would you want him sent off?
eddiedied
04/05/2009 11:02:00
0
I have absolutely nothing against the majority of Newcastle fans. As a Spurs fan who began supporting in the days of "terracing" I can remember Newcastle taking up the entire South stand - no mean feat for a team as far from London as is possible in England - I have always been impressed by the support they have provided to their team in good times and bad. But, If any Newcastle fan thinks they are on the verge of relegation for no other reason than their club is rotten to the core, then they are dellusional. I take no joy from Newcastle being relegated as it could so easily have been Spurs. Spurs have suffered equal problems in terms of rot - the difference betwen the two sides is the speed of acting on various levels to stop it. Whilst Levy has put his hands up and showed some humility in accepting that his vision was faulty, your own owner hasnt. Levy scrapped the hated Director of Football role that saw us fire the best coach we had in years (Jol) and saw us spend untold amounts on average players and untested youngsters. He then fired a manager that could not speak English. By contrast, your own "Spurs supporting" owner undermined Keegan (a manager who has consistently shown a lack of confidence in his appointments) by installing Dennis Wise as DoF - a post that he had not proven himself at. Spurs replaced Ramos with the Premiership experienced, media friendly Redknapp; Newcastle opted for Kinnear who immediately embarked on a meet and hate campaign with the media. Redknapp has spent the season weeding out the non-hackers, consigning the likes of Bentley, Bale and Zokora to the bench whilst boosting the confidence of the beleagured Gomez, Lennon and Modric. By comparison, too many Newcastle players dont seem up for it. I went to the Spurs Newcastle game and they were a shadow of the side that destroyed us at the Lane the previous season. Butt looked a broken man and there was no penetrative threat at all until Martins came on. Ironically, Barton could end up being your saviour; Shearers rant at Barton may well sink into the players minds enough to spark one or two players into life enough to keep you up.
Woodstaworld
06/05/2009 12:53:00
0
I have absolutely nothing against the majority of Newcastle fans. As a Spurs fan who began supporting in the days of "terracing" I can remember Newcastle taking up the entire South stand - no mean feat for a team as far from London as is possible in England - I have always been impressed by the support they have provided to their team in good times and bad. But, If any Newcastle fan thinks they are on the verge of relegation for no other reason than their club is rotten to the core, then they are dellusional. I take no joy from Newcastle being relegated as it could so easily have been Spurs. Spurs have suffered equal problems in terms of rot - the difference betwen the two sides is the speed of acting on various levels to stop it. Whilst Levy has put his hands up and showed some humility in accepting that his vision was faulty, your own owner hasnt. Levy scrapped the hated Director of Football role that saw us fire the best coach we had in years (Jol) and saw us spend untold amounts on average players and untested youngsters. He then fired a manager that could not speak English. By contrast, your own "Spurs supporting" owner undermined Keegan (a manager who has consistently shown a lack of confidence in his appointments) by installing Dennis Wise as DoF - a post that he had not proven himself at. Spurs replaced Ramos with the Premiership experienced, media friendly Redknapp; Newcastle opted for Kinnear who immediately embarked on a meet and hate campaign with the media. Redknapp has spent the season weeding out the non-hackers, consigning the likes of Bentley, Bale and Zokora to the bench whilst boosting the confidence of the beleagured Gomez, Lennon and Modric. By comparison, too many Newcastle players dont seem up for it. I went to the Spurs Newcastle game and they were a shadow of the side that destroyed us at the Lane the previous season. Butt looked a broken man and there was no penetrative threat at all until Martins came on. Ironically, Barton could end up being your saviour; Shearers rant at Barton may well sink into the players minds enough to spark one or two players into life enough to keep you up.
Woodstaworld
06/05/2009 12:53:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Newcastle United Articles

Officials - Brighton v Newcastle (28/2/17)

The Football League have now announced the Match Day officials that will take charge of the game between Brighton and Newcastle United this Tuesday.

Video - Newcastle 2-2 Bristol City

Newcastle's late equaliser saw us come from two down to deny Bristol City a win. A 2-2 draw would have been taken by the Magpies but cost top spot when Brighton won.

Diame In Team Of The Tournament (27/2/17)

Newcastle United are represented in the latest League Cup Team of the Tournament that was selected ahead of Sunday's show piece Final.

Rafa Backs Under-Fire Players

The two players that have had more grief than any other after the Bristol City home draw were Karl Darlow and Aleksandar Mitrovic.

Archived TOTT Articles

TOTT articles from

Site Journalists

TNMW
Editor email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Bristol City MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Darlow10%
Yedlin0%
Lascelles0%
Clark8%
Dummett0%
Shelvey25%
Colback0%
Ritchie16%
Perez0%
Atsu33%
Mitrovic0%
Sub - Diame0%
Sub - Gouffran8%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Brighton 33 21 8 4 71 31
2 Newcastle 33 22 4 7 70 37
3 Huddersfield 33 20 5 8 65 8
4 Leeds Utd 34 19 4 11 61 12
5 Reading 34 18 6 10 60 2
6 Sheff Wed 34 17 7 10 58 9
7 Fulham 33 14 11 8 53 17
8 Norwich 34 15 7 12 52 11
9 Preston 34 14 10 10 52 5
10 Barnsley 34 14 8 12 50 4
11 Derby County 33 13 9 11 48 6
12 Cardiff 34 13 7 14 46 -2
13 Brentford 33 12 7 14 43 2
14 Birmingham 34 11 10 13 43 -13
15 Ipswich 34 10 12 12 42 -7
16 Q.P.R. 34 11 7 16 40 -11
17 Aston Villa 33 9 12 12 39 -7
18 Forest 34 10 7 17 37 -12
19 Burton 34 9 9 16 36 -13
20 Wolves 32 9 8 15 35 -5
21 Bristol City 33 9 6 18 33 -6
22 Wigan 34 7 10 17 31 -10
23 Blackburn 32 7 9 16 30 -13
24 Rotherham 34 4 5 25 17 -45
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Newcastle United Results (view all)

Newcastle United Fixtures (view all)

Feb 28 2017 7:45PM : Brighton & Hove Albion (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 4 2017 5:30PM : Huddersfield Town (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 7 2017 8:00PM : Reading (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 11 2017 3:00PM : Fulham (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Mar 18 2017 3:00PM : Birmingham City (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Apr 1 2017 3:00PM : Wigan Athletic (H)
Sky Bet Championship

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Toon_NoMatterWot151
2.CuckFan114
3.PieMag103
4.Mcnamee6748
5.keggy_keagal41
6.billybobcat28
7.Finn_the_Dog24
8.daftladguy19
9.officemonkey19
10.McCreery17
The Vital Football Members League