Vital Football

Latest Newcastle United News

Post Mackems: Scores on the doors

Post Mackems: Scores on the doors

Harper - 8/10 - Really unlucky with the goal, decent (ish) kicking and reasonably commanding on crosses. Not a bad effort to start the post-Given era.

Taylor - 8/10 - Good efforts going forward, especially to win us the penalty. Reasonably solid coming across to cover a number of times for the centre halves.

Coloccini - 4/10 - Struggled massively. Wonder whether the lad will end up becoming another costly Boumsong level mistake. The fact Kinnear is after a Hyppia figure reflects shockingly on a £10m player.

Bassong - 9/10 - Ran Jonas close for MOTM. Put in a fantastic shift against Jones and only Coloccini`s continual failure to handle Cisse robbed him of a clean sheet.

Enrique - 7/10 - Needs to work on his crossing but linked well with Jonas. Can he manage it consistently for 10 games though is the next question?

Duff - 5/10 - Never in the game, despite a couple of interesting crosses. Needs to shape up physically for the relegation battle.

Butt - 5/10 - Looked very leaden legged in the midfield. Almost cost us the match with his untimely header back to Coloccini.

Nolan - 6/10 - Steady rather than spectacular. Never got a sniff at goal but should figure more in an away day formation.

Jonas - 9.5/10 - Nearly a 10 but lacked some end product at times. Scared the mackems witless and the fact most of their bookings came through hacking him down says it all.

Ameobi - 5/10 - Got an extra mark for the penalty but was massively outshone by Carroll. Looks so leggy and off the pace it`s criminal.

Carroll - 7/10 - Was reasonably satisfied and missed out on a derby goal when his header flicked the bar.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Ross Molyneux
Date:Sunday February 1 2009
Time: 6:24PM


Disappointing game, really. But still... a draw is better than a loss... especially against Sunderland.
01/02/2009 22:11:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Newcastle United Articles

Newcastle Fans Worried Over Rafa`s Comments About Striker

It has been tremendously frustrating seeing Islam Slimani on the sidelines since his loan move from Leicester in January.

Fans Laud Midfielder`s Career Turnaround At Newcastle

Mo Diame says he is hoping the international break does not put to an end his run of good form.

NUFC Accounts Won't Paint The Whole Picture

The self inflicted state of Newcastle United under Mike Ashley is a rhetorical statement that is borne out of the way it is run.

Supporters Respond To Rafa's Praise for Newcastle Duo

Rafa has been full of praise for two of our defenders. Jamaal Lascelles and Paul Dummett have been singled out for praise by the manager.

Newcastle United Archived Articles

TOTT articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Southampton MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Joselu0%
Sub - Atsu1%
Sub - Merino1%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Newcastle United Results (view all)

Newcastle United Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

7.The Pyrry20
9.Harry's Boy15
Vital Football Comment