Vital Football

Latest Newcastle United News

Window Shopping: NUFC's defence

Window Shopping: NUFC's defence

Following the 5-1 drubbing at Liverpool the defence gained a modicum of respect back by holding Hull`s reserves to a 0-0 at the KC Stadium. However that only papered over the current cracks.

At the moment we`ve got Habib Beye out until March which is a major blow. Beye was our only specialist right full back and this showed against the Scousers as they pezzled that side of the pitch. Moving inside we`re probably better stocked in terms of numbers but not in quality. Taylor has failed to progress in four years of playing first team football, still making the same old mistakes.

Coloccini hasn`t justified his £10m tag at all. We got an early shot of his frailty in the air when faced by Coventry City in the Carling Cup, with the Argentinian failing badly when challenged by defenders coming up from the back. This was again prevelant against the Scousers as Hyppia ran riot at set pieces.

Bassong has come on leaps and bounds but it seems criminal to suggest he is the solution to our problems. He started the season as a back up and now looks to be our number one defender but, only in his early 20s, he is bound to suffer a form dip. Definitely a starter but would benefit from an old head beside him.

At left back we again struggle. Enrique got slaughtered by Lennon of Spurs and is so often on the treatment table that we`ve had to rely on N`Zogbia, who will never make a left back as long as I`ve got a pulse.

In reserve we have David Edgar, out of contract in the summer and not Premiership standard, as shown consistently since 2007.

In my line of thinking it`s patently obvious we need a leader in the back four, who need not be a world beater but must have some nous about positioning and organisation.

We need a right back capable of challenging Beye for the position when fit and capable of coming in and making a difference now.

Lastly we desperately need a specialist left back to cover for Enrique as he is sure to break down and be out for another month imminently.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Ross Molyneux
Date:Sunday January 4 2009
Time: 5:54PM

Login to post a comment

Recent Newcastle United Articles

Newcastle Fans Worried Over Rafa`s Comments About Striker

It has been tremendously frustrating seeing Islam Slimani on the sidelines since his loan move from Leicester in January.

Fans Laud Midfielder`s Career Turnaround At Newcastle

Mo Diame says he is hoping the international break does not put to an end his run of good form.

NUFC Accounts Won't Paint The Whole Picture

The self inflicted state of Newcastle United under Mike Ashley is a rhetorical statement that is borne out of the way it is run.

Supporters Respond To Rafa's Praise for Newcastle Duo

Rafa has been full of praise for two of our defenders. Jamaal Lascelles and Paul Dummett have been singled out for praise by the manager.

Newcastle United Archived Articles

TOTT articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Southampton MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Sub - Joselu0%
Sub - Atsu1%
Sub - Merino1%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Newcastle United Results (view all)

Newcastle United Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

7.The Pyrry20
9.Harry's Boy15
The Vital Football Members League