Vital Football

Latest Newcastle United News

Who`s to blame? The players

Who`s to blame? The players

Nearly 24 hours since the derby shocker and it`s time for the blame game. Just who should carry the can for our first loss on Wearside since 1980?

The players

Lets face it - they were the ones on the pitch and they underperformed. Let`s look at the contribution of each:

Shay Given - Made a smart stop from Cisse to keep the scores at 1-1 and made some timely interventions. Blameless. Even had to put up with one of the Unwashed trying to give it large after the second goal.

Habib Beye - One of his worst performances in a black and white shirt. Offered nothing in attack and wasn`t helped by the lack of legs on Geremi.

Steven Taylor - A usual Platoon-style handball could have cost us dearly, especially with Richardson`s ability with free-kicks. Dealt with Cisse / Jones better than his partner in crime.

Fabriccio Coloccini - Struggled so much in the air with the wind and the physical nature of Sunderland`s attackers. Really needed a strong display but he was inept.

Sebastian Bassong - Definitely targeted by the mackems as a weak link and they definitely got a lot of joy down his side, including the first goal. Answers the question over why Keegan was so desperate to get a specialist left back in.

Geremi - Ignore the fact he provided the free kick cross for Shola`s goal, his overall contribution was just so rank. Hit the wall, first man and anything but our players on the rest, didn`t aid Beye and looked like he needed three or four touches before doing anything. We took £12m for Milner and god do we miss his enterprise down that side. A main culprit in the debacle.

Nicky Butt - Brave, but shouldn`t have been playing. Gave away the free kick they scored from, failed to track his runner for the first and looked legless. Needed a painkilling injection as well. Another culprit but was a more the victim of our lack of options in the squad.

Danny Guthrie - Looked like he was sh*tting it in the tunnel before hand and got himself needlessly booked early on which gave the mackem`s midfield a massive advantage. Like Scott Parker before him he seems to offer nothing but turning around in circles.

Damien Duff - Just plain sh*te. Offered nothing in attack at all and couldn`t beat his man or the first man. Could N`Zogbia, a veteran of a number of derby matches, done any worse? I don`t think so.

Obafemi Martins - Greedy with the ball and failed to spot opportunities when they came. Wasn`t aided by absolutely nothing in terms of service provided.

Shola Ameobi - Scored, and gave Chimbonda a torrid time, but missed an even easier 1 on 1. Definitely outshone the majority of his teammates though.



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Ross Molyneux
Date:Sunday October 26 2008
Time: 11:56AM

Login to post a comment

Best of International Football News

Recent Newcastle United Articles

Instant Reactions - Bournemouth v Newcastle (24/2/18)

Following today's clash between Bournemouth and Newcastle United, here are the instant reactions from both managers.

Stats: Bournemouth v Newcastle United

All the stats from Bournemouth (2) vs (2) Newcastle United, Dean Court, 24/2/18 Att: 10,808

One Transfer Deadline Was Never Enough Was It

You've got to love the football authorities, if transfer deadline days weren't ridiculous enough already - they've now begun to breed.

Rafa Praises Shelvey

Rafa Benitez spoke highly of Jonjo Shelvey today in his pre Bournemouth press conference.

Newcastle United Archived Articles

TOTT articles from

Site Journalists

TNMW
Editor email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Bournemouth MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Dubravka35%
Yedlin0%
Lascelles16%
Lejeune0%
Dummett16%
Ritchie0%
Shelvey0%
Diame0%
Kenedy0%
Perez0%
Gayle33%
Sub - Atsu0%
Sub - Hayden0%
Sub - Manquillo0%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Newcastle United Results (view all)

Newcastle United Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Toon_NoMatterWot68
2.crooktownmags57
3.Mcnamee6735
4.keggy_keagal33
5.Rexn29
6.Harry's Boy26
7.PieMag24
8.markylad7420
9.Bruce6819
10.The Owl17
Vital Football Comment